The Bone Folder
❧ ❡ ❈ ➻

Why I Say authoritarian Instead of Fascist

You may notice that in this essay I do not use the term Fascist to describe the Trump administration and its followers, unlike many folks on the left. While it's a term I may use in casual conversation, I'm keeping it out of my public writing. As I writer, I do want to insist on the accuracy of words and I feel that the terms Fascist and Nazi are buzzwords and insults more so than descriptors.This is not new. Nearly 80 years ago, George Orwell said that the word Fascist in English had become a meaningless analog for the word "bully." And as almost every child raised in the United States learns in school that Nazis were evil guys that we fought to defend the free world, the word "Nazi" in our culture has come to mean anyone we don't like. That a word like "Feminazi" gained such traction on the Right shows how little historical or political understanding one needs to have in order to call someone a Nazi.

Some may defend the use of these words as accurately describing the current political situation in the US, but I think they instead feel cheap. When someone starts throwing around the words Nazi and Fascist, it makes me want to stop listening, even though I may agree with them politically. The adjectives that I prefer to use to describe the Trump administration are not more flattering, but I think they are more accurate: authoritarian and imperialist. I think it is also fair to call Trump a dictator, in ambition if perhaps not in fact. That is, after all, a term he has applied to himself. These words are accurate, descriptive, and insofar as they can be, neutral.

But more than that, when we reduce people who voted for Trump to a bunch of Fascists and Nazis, we lose the opportunity to understand the appeal of authoritarian leadership. And without understanding it, we can't turn people away from it. In all historically Fascist nations, after all, most people supported it. Why would Americans be any different? It can be difficult in hindsight, after you have been told all your life that Fascism is evil, to understand why it appealed to so many people. On its face Fascism was an ideology of community and unity that encouraged a spirit of oneness. It was sternly beautiful. Fascist aesthetics were awe-inspiring and made people want to give themselves to this cause. Even the Nazi tourism bureau was called "Strength though Joy" (surely the name of a self-care workshop that someone has offered online in the past decade.) The problem with Fascism, of course, is its shadow side: the belief that in order to have a glorious, unified society, you have to exterminate all of the people who won't fit into it. Not just people who are objects of ethnic hatred (Jews and Romanis) or political enemies (communists and socialists) or people who ally themselves to a higher power than their dictator (religious people), but also people who can't or won't support the great society by working or having children.

Of course there are people in the United States today who have remarkably similar beliefs to Nazis and want to make the United States into a Christian, patriarchal nation with a race-based hierarchy that places white people at the top. They are the core of Trump's followers, but they did not get him elected; they likely do not even form the majority of the people who voted for Trump in 2024. No, the people who got Trump elected don't have a grand vision of Fascist America; they were not acting on ideals. The greater majority are instead people who decided to try giving up some of their rights and freedoms for economic stability—haven't we all?—and are finding out whether or not the trade-off is worth it for them. It seems strange, but there is evidence that a preference for authoritarian leadership, called the Authoritarian Follower Personality by sociologists, has some basis in genetics. That is, some people are born with nervous systems that are wired to be less open to new experiences, less trustful of others, and more prone to follow rules. (I find it ironic, given the Nazis' belief in racial hierarchy and genetic purity, that Nazism itself my have had genetic roots.) Authoritarian Followers both prefer authoritarian leaders and act as authoritarians in their own lives. They find safety and order in hierarchy and punishment, willing to accept even extreme subjugation under authoritarian leaders as long as they are guaranteed a well-defined place in a hierarchy. (note)

I do not mean to say that some people are genetically destined to be murderous stooges of authoritarian regimes. There are many factors that shape behavior. But it may be the case that baked into any population there is a group of people who in more benign environments are just ass-kissers and tattle-tales, but may commit or approve of horrific acts in contexts where stress and fear are high. Beyond that group, many otherwise-predisposed people will also willingly give their power to an authoritarian when their environment feels out of control. And as authoritarian leadership, of course, causes stress, fear, and powerlessness, the cycle devolves into some of the worst human situations imaginable.

Glibly dismissing Trump voters as Fascists make us far less capable of understanding the broad appeal authoritarianism. But it is also its own form of dehumanization and vilification. Authoritarians are human, predictably behaving the way that many humans have done when faced with uncertainty and personal hardship. I plainly call them authoritarians because I have no interest in downplaying or disguising the immorality of their actions, but don't I pretend that, had I lived my life under the same circumstances, I would act differently from them.

Also, by targeting Fascism specifically, we do not keep our guard up for authoritarianism wherever it manifests. When you look at the broad details, can you tell a difference between the actions of Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin? Between Bashar al-Assad and Augusto Pinochet? It all works the same way: propaganda, secret police, purges, disappearances, mass murders, pogroms, death camps, historical erasure. And while the United States is far from home-growing the kind of leftist dictatorship that some folks on the right fear, when we insist that everyone who disagrees with us is a Fascist, we miss being able to connect with our opponents on this very real point: everyone is afraid of being oppressed even if they have different ideas of what oppression means.

I am not taking a "horseshoe theory" stance in which the ideologies of the right and left eventually converge at their extreme ends. In the arbitrary left-center-right political paradigm of our time, the extreme right and the left have fundamental differences that cannot be reconciled. But horseshoe theory is appealing to casual observers of history because it is obvious that extremists, despite the opposition of their political affiliations, are happy to employ the same techniques in pursuit of them.

Instead, I am making a distinction between content and form: content being the specific political beliefs of a group of people, and form being the actual strategies by which they are carried out. It is not that the political differences between Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin were meaningless, but their methods of execution (pun intended) were very similar. We must watch both form and content closely and be able to differentiate them from one another. While the content of our political ideologies is where we theorize about morality, the form of our political strategies is where we actually exercise our morals. No political ideology on its own can save one from becoming, or loving, a monster.

Note This partly explains why authoritarianism has appeal across political lines, nations, and religions. For example, so many Evangelical Christians approach their religion as an authoritarian regime, despite the anti-authoritarian teachings of Jesus. If you believe that God is a dictator with the right to punish people who break the rules, and even collectively punish those near the rule-breakers, it makes sense why ostensibly private things become a matter of public concern. If a nation tolerates people breaking "the rules" around gender and sexuality, for instance, the rule-breakers become an existential threat to everyone else. There is nothing stopping God from exercising his right to punish the many for the sins of a few.

This is the source of the disconnect between libertarian (in the broadest sense) and authoritarian approaches to morality. Libertarians are baffled that people lose their minds over obviously harmless, personal choices like sex positions and clothing. But rule-breaking, for Authoritarian Followers, goes against the very order of life itself. At the same time, Authoritarian Followers have often been unable to see the immorality of extreme acts like murder and torture if they believe they are committed under a legitimate authority, hence the self-justification of actual Nazis: "I was just following orders." (return)